by dargom3 on 13 May 2009, 15:31
Got back late last night from RING duty. Overall I give it a B minus. Yzhky & I went -- DargomMom doesn't do Wagner. Production outstanding, as we all know. Morris -- outstanding, too -- he defeated that wobble and gave the perf I hoped for. I understand from Opera L that Sirius bdcst the perf, tho' Juntwait had said they would not. Did they? PD was sick and walked off stage during act 1 -- his cover, Gary Lehman, was very good -- poor guy had to walk out of the wings and start his perf with "Winterstuerme!" He was well received. West gave us a Siggy that would make Melchior revolve in his grave, but he got thru it, and had the notes at the ends of both operas. His concept of the character is a bit too much Li'l Abner, but he can sing the roles. He even had a real high C in the hunt scene just before his death. Every Siggy I've ever heard has always finessed that note, but West grabbed it and held on as if his life depended on it. Watson is a very provincial underpowered dull Brunnie -- her best effort was in the trio in Act 2 of G'D, where she showed some fire. Immolation was very bland. I got not one single frisson the entire four evenings, even when the "Redemption thru love" motif returns at the very end -- that place always gets to me. Best voices as voices: Pieczonka as Sieglinde; Fink as Alberich (a fine artist); Harmer as Freia; and Naef as Fricka and Waltraute (G'D). Jeemmee and the band were good, as expected, but not as good as I had hoped -- lots of ragged playing and blats, esp. in G'D. Of course they are tired! They need a break! I can forgive them a lot, and the public did -- there was a huge long ovation at the end -- they even had to bring the bow lights up again after they had been shut off, because we wouldn't stop applauding. All told, a fine event. It could have been better, but there have been so many cancellations and dropouts that even getting the bugger on stage was an effort. I'm very glad that Gelb has decided not to deep-six the production -- he may need to use it again!
On our off nights we went to Carnegie for the Mahler fest put on by the Berliner Staatskapelle, with Barenboim & Boulez. We heard Barenboim do the First -- extraordinarily exciting and revelatory perf!!! I didn't know the 1st had so much music in it!!! -- and Boulez the third-- dull, pedantic, boring -- how can people say that he can do Mahler? On Sat eve DargomMom went back alone for more Mahler -- the 4th under Boulez -- and was decidedly unimpressed. The TIMES critic (Oestreich) thought Boulez's perfs were the cat's pajamas -- but the public knew, and gave Barenboim a HUGE success and Boulez tepid appreciation. I'm very gladto have seen the Schenk -- bravi tutti!!!